AnalPhilosopher

“[I]t is ambition enough to be employed as an under-labourer in clearing the ground a little,
and removing some of the rubbish that lies in the way to knowledge.” —John Locke, 1689

“[P]hilosophy can no more show a man what he should attach importance to
than geometry can show a man where he should stand.” —Peter Winch, 1968

From Today's New York Times

To the Editor:

"Spies, Lies and Wiretaps" (editorial, Jan. 29) is an eloquent call to United States citizens to wake up and notice the constitutional crisis in our midst.

Spying on Americans without a warrant breaks current law and sets President Bush above the law. The Bush administration is trying to convince us that it needs to bypass our country's system of checks and balances in order to save us from the terrorists.

But just look at the facts. We already have laws in place that make it easy to spy on terrorists. These laws both make our country strong in the fight against terrorism and uphold the Constitution by requiring warrants.

The Bush administration is wasting precious time and energy fighting to destroy the rights of ordinary Americans rather than using a system that already works. We need to defend our Constitution, our greatest hope in fighting terrorism.

Kathy Rappaport
Santa Fe, N.M., Jan. 29, 2006

Kevin Stroup (mail):
Broadly, I agree with this woman. However, it is the nasty little details that can complicate this perspective. What if, one terrorist is not American but is talking to an American terrorist and both get new phones every 24 hours? What do you do? Traditional court order takes too long. What if both terrorist are Americans but are overseas? Does our constitution apply to them? I do not know, I am not a lawyer.
Nevertheless, this woman does have a point. Remember, these are people that have been ACCUSED of being terrorist. They have not been convicted in a court of law of act(s) of terrorism. Do we start denying people their constitutional rights based upon an accusation or suspicion?
1.31.2006 7:08pm
Sean (mail):
Rubbish - the President is just exercising previously approved powers to listen in on foreign communications. Those who claim otherwise are just Stuck on Stupid.
2.1.2006 3:18pm
Account:
Password:
Remember info?